Head to head
Melissa Bumstead vs Andrea Shaw
Height, weight, measurements, age and contest record side by side.
Quick verdict
- Andrea Shaw is the taller of the two at 5'5 (166 cm), about 4 cm more than Melissa Bumstead.
- Melissa Bumstead is listed as heavier, at about 140 lb, roughly 151 lb more than Andrea Shaw.
- In contest wins, Andrea Shaw leads with 7 first-place finishes against 1 for Melissa Bumstead.
- Andrea Shaw has 4 Olympia titles.
- Andrea Shaw is the older of the two at 42, 7 years older than Melissa Bumstead.
Measure
Melissa Bumstead
Andrea Shaw
Age
35
42
Height
5'5" · 163 cm
5'5 · 166 cm
Weight
140 lb · 164 kg
209 lb · 95 kg
Arms
—
18 in
Olympia titles
0
4
Contest wins
1
7
Podium finishes
3
7
Division
—
Women's Bodybuilding
Debut
2010s
2014
Hometown
Toronto
Detroit, Michigan
Nationality
Canada
United States
Measurements are approximate and come from each athlete’s profile. Wins, podiums and Olympia titles are counted from the listed contest history. The crown marks who leads each row.
Melissa Bumstead vs Andrea Shaw: quick answers
Who is taller, Melissa Bumstead or Andrea Shaw?
Andrea Shaw is taller at about 166 cm, compared with 163 cm for Melissa Bumstead.
Who is heavier, Melissa Bumstead or Andrea Shaw?
Melissa Bumstead is listed at about 140 lb, and Andrea Shaw at about 209 lb. Stage weight changes from season to season.
Who has won more contests, Melissa Bumstead or Andrea Shaw?
Melissa Bumstead has 1 first-place finishes and Andrea Shaw has 7, based on their listed contest history.
How old are Melissa Bumstead and Andrea Shaw?
Melissa Bumstead is 35 and Andrea Shaw is 42.
